TL;DR
Astral Codex Ten’s Open Thread 453 combines its weekly invitation for reader discussion with updates on a California House race, college meetups and grants related to transformative AI. The grant organizers say they will distribute up to $10 million; the post does not specify how much will be awarded or when.
Astral Codex Ten’s Open Thread 453 invites readers to discuss any topic and carries three updates: a response from Jamie Joyce, a challenger in California’s 12th District House race; newly planned college effective-altruism meetups; and a grant announcement promising up to $10 million for work on middle powers and transformative AI. The thread does not give a publication date or a schedule for the grants.
Prime made for students and young adults
- Fast, free delivery for dorm and study essentials
- Prime Video and Amazon Music included
- Member-only deals
The post describes itself as the blog’s weekly visible open thread, where readers can post questions or discuss subjects beyond the main articles. It also points readers to an unofficial subreddit, Discord server, bulletin board and in-person meetups. The post says most content is free, while some is available to subscribers.
In a note about California’s 12th District House race, the author says a spring ballot-recommendations post favored the incumbent, whom the author described as boring, because Joyce seemed eccentric and unlikely to win. Joyce contacted the author and asked for a change of view. The author says the two candidates will face each other again in the general election, declines to revisit the May comments in this thread, and says they may reconsider the race in a future November-election post. The thread links to Joyce’s response and recommends it to interested district voters.
The meetup update names Oxford, University College Dublin and the University of the Philippines as locations with meetups planned. Separately, Astralis Foundation and Macroscopic Ventures announced that they would distribute up to $10 million in grants for work on “middle powers and transformative AI.” The post describes eligible work as research, training, public writing and new organizations examining what countries beyond the United States and China can do as AI develops.
Grants Focus on Countries Beyond US and China
The grant announcement gives the thread its largest financial figure and signals interest in how countries outside the two AI powers named in the post might contribute to the field. Its stated scope spans research, training, public writing and new organizations, suggesting that applications need not be limited to technical research. The organizers’ phrase “middle powers” frames the work around countries beyond the United States and China, though the post does not define which countries qualify or how proposals will be assessed.
The planned campus meetups also extend the post’s community updates beyond the blog’s online spaces. Naming three universities gives readers concrete places to follow up, while the thread’s links direct interested people to details and, for the grant program, an application page. The post itself does not report how many people will attend meetups or how much funding is available for any one project.
The election note matters to voters seeking information about the district race because it links to a candidate’s response after the author previously endorsed her opponent. That link gives Joyce a chance to address readers directly, but the post does not adopt her arguments or announce a revised endorsement. The author’s possible reconsideration is conditional on a future election post.
Popular right now

Shark AI Ultra Robot Vacuum with Matrix Clean and Self-Empty Base

Bose QuietComfort Wireless Noise-Cancelling Headphones, Sandstone

KitchenAid Artisan Mini Tilt-Head Stand Mixer, 3.5 Quart, Aqua Sky Blue
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
A Weekly Thread With Three Updates
Open Thread 453 is presented as a recurring discussion space rather than a standalone report devoted to one event. Its format combines an open invitation to readers with short announcements from the Astral Codex Ten community. The source material offers no details about the thread’s publication date, so its references to a spring ballot post and the coming general election cannot be placed on a specific calendar.
The political note points back to a ballot-recommendations post published in the spring. The author describes the earlier choice as a vote for the incumbent, based on the author’s assessment of Joyce’s prospects and manner. The current thread adds that Joyce requested a link to her response, but it does not reproduce the response’s arguments. Readers would need to follow the link to evaluate her case.
The grants and meetup notices are also brief. The thread directs readers to a list for meetup details and to an application page for the grant program. Its description of the grant aim is the available explanation of the organizers’ focus: what countries beyond the United States and China can do to help shape AI’s development. The post supplies no eligibility rules or award criteria in the provided material.
At the end, the author recommends four comments from a separate Astral Codex Ten post, “Mysteries of AI Generalization.” The listed commenters are Eliezer Yudkowsky, Ezra Newman, Elias Schmied and Stuart Armstrong. Their linked comments address generalization failures, distinctions among stages of AI model training, a claim about “Hacker Opus,” and mechanisms behind emergent misalignment. These are recommendations to readers, not new findings established by Open Thread 453.
““up to $10 million””
— Astral Codex Ten, describing the grant announcement
Grant Terms and Election Views Remain Open
The thread does not specify the grant application deadline, award timeline, eligibility requirements or selection process. “Up to $10 million” is a ceiling, not a confirmed total payout, and the post does not state whether the money comes from one fund or multiple sources. It also does not report how many applications are expected or which projects may receive support.
For the House race, the supplied text does not include Joyce’s response, the incumbent’s position or further details about either candidate. The author’s earlier preference is described, but no fresh endorsement is made. Whether the author revisits the contest in a November-election post remains uncertain. The meetup notice likewise gives no dates, organizers or attendance information for the three university locations.
Applications and Election Coverage Ahead
Readers interested in the grant program can consult the application page linked from the thread for its current terms and submission details. The post’s announcement does not state when decisions will be made or when grants will be distributed, so those milestones remain to be confirmed by the organizers.
People seeking details about the Oxford, University College Dublin and University of the Philippines meetups can check the list linked in the post. In the California race, voters can read Joyce’s linked response; the author says a further discussion may appear in a post about the November election, but does not commit to publishing one. The thread also directs readers to the recommended comments on AI generalization for the arguments and distinctions those commenters make.
Key Questions
What is Open Thread 453?
It is Astral Codex Ten’s weekly open discussion thread, inviting readers to post about any topic. This edition also includes political, meetup and grant updates.
Who is Jamie Joyce, and what does the post say about her?
The post identifies Joyce as a challenger in California’s 12th District House race. It says she contacted the author after a spring endorsement of the incumbent and asked the author to link her response. The thread does not reproduce that response.
How much grant funding was announced?
Astralis Foundation and Macroscopic Ventures said they would distribute up to $10 million for work on middle powers and transformative AI. The post does not give the final amount, award schedule or selection criteria.
Where are new college meetups planned?
The thread lists planned meetups at Oxford, University College Dublin and the University of the Philippines. It directs readers to a linked list for further details.
Source: rss
